Forum Replies Created
-
1 user thanked author for this post.
Only joking BS.
Pretty much agree with your ratings other than would have given Green and Onariase 1 less each.
1 user thanked author for this post.
No wonder we are bottom of the league.
According to BS we are only playing with 8 players.
1 user thanked author for this post.
But true
1 user thanked author for this post.
Can’t believe Green gets the nod ahead of Scrimshaw or even Loft. Or even the club cat.
If Hill can make a footballer out of Devarn he should get the Old Trafford gig at the end of the season.
Rowe now being reinvented as a defensive midfielder? Will someone play the lad as right back until he gains more experience? He is a decent prospect at full back but he is not ready to play multiple positions.
As ever I hope Green, Rowe and Hill prove me wrong.
4 users thanked author for this post.
Sounded refreshingly honest to me. Was proud of his players effort whilst accepting they are not very good. Talked of improving the quality of his hard working less technical players and getting more work out of the more competent players.
Makes a lot of sense and more interesting than “We trained really well this week”.
Did not sense the distancing mentioned but let’s face it – Hill did not pick any of the 25 players he has inherited and would have been unlikely to pick more than 4 or 5 of them.
One of the very finest centre backs to put on an Iron shirt in my time.
No unchallenged pathways through the middle when Frank was playing. R.I.P.
12 users thanked author for this post.
Never noticed any beguiling coming in my direction Daz.
Mind you I’m just one of the idiots that keeps handing over his cash.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Hold the front page. The Iron don’t have a team full of good players.
Seems to be a bit of a surprise to some posters on here. Where have you been the last three and a half seasons?
Keith Hill has had 17 days and 3 whole league games and we still concede chances to top 6 teams. What has the man been doing with his time.
What I saw tonight was a team with very little in the way of quality stand up and be counted against a very decent League 2 team and gain a point. Yes they rode their luck and better teams would have punished them. The good news is there are only 4 or 5 better teams in this League. Workrate and energy is all you have got to work with against better quality teams. Show those things against lesser teams and (some) results will come.
By all means criticise the events and people that got us in this mess but berating £500 quid a week footballers for their lack of quality is ridiculous. Especially from people that can’t be arsed to go and watch them.
Well done tonight lads for the shift you put in.
6 users thanked author for this post.
Agree Beeston is a better footballer and more likely to score without the aid of penalties.
He works hard but does tire in games so I suspect he is one of the ones needing to improve his stamina before he starts regularly under Hill.
Also want to see him as a 10 rather than as a holding player. That job is for Pugh or Kenyon.
1 user thanked author for this post.
What no place for our goalscorer from Saturday and for me Rowe for all his inexperience is a safer bet than Millen.
Particularly in a game where we might have to defend for periods.
1 user thanked author for this post.
I always feel a 50-50 mix of both when I go.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Loft is exactly the player he was when he arrived. Cox had many faults but perhaps the biggest fault of all was not one player is any better than they were when they arrived at the club.
O’Malley and Watson have improved but I think that was despite Cox rather than because of him.
Loft is half a good centre forward. He has pace and is prepared to make a nuisance of himself. What he could not do (and still cant do) is get the ball under control, bring a midfielder or wide player into the game and get moving into the danger area for the return ball.
Will Hill be able to turn him into a proper centre forward? If he listens and works then I suspect he could. Then he really will be too good for bottome of League 2.
Hill has already made progress in 2 weeks turning Hippolyte into someone that could be a footballer which never looked possible while Cox was here.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Can he play upfront?
2 users thanked author for this post.
Ferrite the only way to get fit enough to play high tempo and high press is to play it in matches. You can train for it pre season but not when you have games coming. Especially when you have a Tuesday/Saturday coming up.
The enforced break for FA Cup round 2 weekend will allow some hard fitness work to be done.
I suspect one or two are getting in the team because they are closer to lasting the pace than rather than because they are playing well.
Pugh allegedly got into trouble not training hard enough with Cox so maybe he has further to go than some to get to the required fitness levels. Wilson has no competitive 90 minute appearances to draw on so probably not being considered for that reason.
Kenyon is the only one clearly unfit who is starting I assume for his experience. Counted for nothing when the Mansfield midfielder left him like a beached whale then picked his spot for their equaliser.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Time for a bit of perspective.
Hill has been here 15 days. Had 4 games in that time so has had about 5 days training with the team.
He has inherited a team not match fit enough to play the high tempo pressing game he requires.
He has taken over a team that have been actively trained for 18 months to drop back into shape and hoofing it upfield as far and as quickly as possible.
Out of the 3 players brought in to add experience to the young squad 2 are injured and 1 is well short of match fitness.
Whenever we play a half decent team who are prepared to work hard (e.g. Mansfield) we are going to get beat.
When we play a shite team or a team going through the motions (e.g. Salford) then we might get a result.
When Hill gets them match fit (a month?) and when he can add 2 or 3 genuine League quality players (mid January Swann permitting) then we might win a few points against half decent teams as well.
Let’s be realistic here. Matching last seasons position will be hard graft and a minor miracle. Like most I remain furious with the arrogance and incompetence that has put the club in this position but the manager and the players are the ones we have and they are going to need all the help and support that they can get.
Keep the ground and ownership on the back burner for now and try and help the team and manager to somehow make the great escape.
It could be worse – we could be Manure fans.
13 users thanked author for this post.
Onariase and O’Malley exceptional today.
First time I have left a game this season thinking we might stay up.
Played a club today with much better players than ours and we made them look very ordinary for 60 minutes until we run out of steam.
It’s probably a blessing we will have a free weekend FA cup second round week. Hill will be able to get some real stamina work into the squad.
3 users thanked author for this post.
Get me a pint of what that man is drinking.
4 users thanked author for this post.
Shame the archive Blast Furnace is no longer with us. Be interesting how many howls of protest were posted when Taylor, Wooton, Burgess and Goode left us.
Some players just do better with other clubs. Josh Morris, Duane Holmes and Murray Wallace were not much mourned in their departure from their previous clubs but they certainly looked pretty good once they arrived here. Not to mention Sharpe and Hooper.
It happens all the time and will continue to happen.
6 users thanked author for this post.
When Wootton was trying to make his mark in the first team we were a half decent league 1 side.
Now we are a shite league 2 side he would establish himself no problem.
Doesn’t necessarily mean he has improved much.
1 user thanked author for this post.
