[Heath]

“The Israeli defence minister spoke ot against such comments yesterday and said the plan is to have Palestine under control by Palestinians”.

Did he? And did he do (diddydo) anything to stop it happening,

[Heath]

The Israelis are also acting like a fundamentalist cult. They have no intention of agreeing to a 2 state solution.

[Heath]

“I think the defence should be a lot more measured”.

But all the evidence is proving that it isn’t. The Israelis aren’t listening to anyone and they are intent on driving the Gazans out of Gaza. Been the intention all along.

Pointless talking about a solution. This war will go on and escalate.

[Heath]

“There won’t be any long term peace”.

There won’t. The continued massacre of the Gazans will ensure decades and probably longer trouble for the Israelis.

[Heath]

“Gazans were told to move south, but have to continuously move, which doesn’t seem thought out”.

This comment makes the assumption that the Israeli leaders care. They clearly don’t.

[Heath]

“Antisemitism has risen by 1300% in London”.

And Palestinian deaths, disease and famine has increased by a greater amount in Gaza. A definite ongoing cause of your antisemitism concern.

[Heath]

I have read and re-read the article by Bernie Steinberg and can find no such “comment about Jews” or “support of the ‘resiistance’ on Oct 7th”.

None of your points above are relevant to the specific article or Peston’s comments. Obvious conflation.

[Heath]

Preston acknowledged that antisemitism is on the rise, so I don’t get why you are dismissing his point. Dragging up an example of antisemitism does not add anything to your argument.

[Heath]

Why do we never get an answer?

2 users thanked author for this post.

Iron-awe, Northumbiron

[Heath]

Meanwhile at least 165 Palestinians have been killed and 250 injured in the last 24 hours.

[Heath]

12/20. Same as Sidey as usual!

[Heath]

Refused to answer Question 1, so zero for me!

[Heath]

When you drive around London, the road signs say “The North” as if it’s some mystical single destination.

[Heath]

I have just read my first few posts on the bombing hospitals thread and don’t recognise any of what you claim in the past above.

[Heath]

“engaged reasonably in a detailed and robust manner”

By that, do you mean constant repetition in posts which are way too long.

“so I’m happy to comply with Heath’s diktat and ‘do one.”

But you keep coming back!!

It’s not just your opinions I disagree with. I also think you have a very high opinion of yourself and condescending.

Apologies for taking offence at supporters of mass murder.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Gurnelista

[Heath]

“seems to me to be the giveaway to what YOU would like to see. Ideologically bound … no real interest in the historical realities”.

Seems to me you know sod all about me or my real interests. If you think that continuing to slaughter innocent civilians is going to make Israel more secure in the future, then you are truly blinkered.

[Heath]

Seems to me that you are the one giving orders. Feel free to do one.

[Heath]

Stop trying to justify the mindless killing of civilians by comparing this with other wars. You failed to compare in to Syria, Ukraine and multiple massacres in Africa.

The idea that the Israelis have any intention to agreeing to a 2 state solution was quashed this week.

Stop trying to justify it. The intention all along was to drive the Palestinians out of Gaza.

Gloomy prediction for you. This war will lead to the ultimate destruction of the state of Israel. The thing you don’t want.

[Heath]

“He actually ordered the killings of civilians”.

He might not have publicly ordered it, but he’s doing it all the same.

Dowden trotted out the same meaningless phrase “we expect the Israelis to use restraint” this morning.

They aren’t are they. This Government is supporting massacre and genocide. And given the weeks since our last “chat”, so are you.

[Heath]

“Hamas and the UNRWA could always release some more food to at least help, Egypt could offer more assistance, but they don’t bother”.

Yeah right, how about the murderous Israelis doing less?

[Heath]

Easy, don’t pay your bills!

[Heath]

Cheaply?

It’s our money not their’s!!

1 user thanked author for this post.

open hearth iron

[Heath]

Evil? Is that your word or mine? And where have I requested an apology?

[Heath]

And what exactly did you try? Your position hasn’t changed so don’t get all mighty because you’ve written yet another of your “reasonable” essays.

[Heath]

This isn’t the second world war. Rules of war were established after the second World War. Ignored by the Serbs, Syria, Russia and multiple other states. I don’t expect our Government to support Israel in the breaking of these rules.

[Heath]

Choose your words and be as reasonable as you wish. There is no reasonable defence for the resumption of the massacre of children, mutilation and total destruction.

[Heath]

I just don’t understand why you can’t accept that incarcerating 14 year old boys in military jails for offences such as stone throwing might be wrong.

As Deerey said, this has been going on long before recent events.

[Heath]

“I am allowed to disagree, it’s hardly undermining to disagree with comments making out the Palestinians in shackles were in shackles for no reason”.

I never said they were detained for no reason. But some of the children are 14 and are detained for indefinite periods in adult military jails for throwing stones.

It was you who escalated their so-called offences to attempted murder.

Your responses show you are biased, and do not reflect your previous positions on other armed conflicts. You call out the Israeli leaders, but then seem to support every action they are taking.

[Heath]

And to top it off, they bring dodgy Dave Cameron back into Government. No accountability whatsoever, whilst the only bit I agree with you BS, the poorer Brits continue to get poorer.

1 user thanked author for this post.

bartonscorpion

[Heath]

Brexit. The restriction of British businesses to trade tariff free and the freedom to live and work anywhere in the EU in order to exchange 300k EU workers and students with 700k workers and students mostly from India, Nigeria and China.

Is that what you voted for BS?

[Author]

Posts