Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I know SST tries his best but to say the quality control on this forum is lax is an understatement. I would ban the whole lot if it was up to me get this back to how it was, an actual forum you could actually enjoy without certain people trying their hardest to ruin it for everybody else.
Oh the irony.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Could they not have moved it to Ilkeston?
2 users thanked author for this post.
It’s the players – the only common denominator.
My biggest worry for next season is how many are still under contract.
Getting rid of contracted players isn’t easy.Which players? The 14 signed since January? A number of the contracted players for next season are Dean signings (Chapman, Elliott) and most of the others are just inexperienced youngsters (Lewis, Foster, Shrimpton). And Tom Pugh whose contract was extended under Dean’s watch I believe.
Aside from Beestin, I don’t think any of the contracted players were with the club in August (in the first team at least), so why do we think that another complete overhaul will make any difference? We’ve been throwing the pieces up in the air every 6 months for years and we keep getting worse results. At some point, we need to consider other options.
Can’t comment on his tactics but I hope he’s not as defeatist in the dressing room as he is in his interviews, he comes across as anything but a leader. I always wasn’t impressed with the way he seemed to wash his hands of any responsibility for the results since he took over in his interview on Saturday – saying that it needed a lot of turning round and a lot of new players – well, you signed most of the squad Jimmy, so why should we trust you to do it all over again?
2 users thanked author for this post.
Bystander give it a rest you’re a quid shop, glue sniffing version of Miss Marple.
IB
Your fascination ,no obsession with hunting down DH to the extent of what his favourite bog roll is and if hes tanga or boxer really has become more tedious than the media v Harry n Megs … to you and a hand full of others it may be of interest and make your trousers move alas me and im guessing most other normal SUFC fans just dont give a shit and are simply waiting to see the outcome re the GP issue ..DH saved our club paid off its tax and other debts for that alone i am very gratefulWhy are we blaming the messenger?
3 users thanked author for this post.
Good enough defensively though to add cover to a more defensively sound LB. I think he’d flourish on the wing. Another important thing about him is that he doesn’t get injured too often either.
I think we could do a hell of a lot worse then him and plus he’s versatile as he can play in CM at a push too.
It’s amazing how often attacking left backs don’t convert into left wingers, probably because the skillsets are more different than people realise. We saw it tried at Scunthorpe with Marcus Williams; we saw it at England with Ashley Cole & Wayne Bridge, it never worked. Running onto an overlap is very different from beating a man from a standing start, for example.
1 user thanked author for this post.
If it was all about the football Pat, you wouldn’t pick Scunthorpe United as your team to follow!
2 users thanked author for this post.
11 Bishops? Jeez, I would not pay to watch that team. Most over-rated player in Scunthorpe’s history.
24 march 2018 the day we sacked Graham Alexander
A symptom of worrying about not reaching the Championship and a panicked response?
‘A’ Toney would have probably signed for us in the championship rather than Peterborough in a lower league then always a chance of staying there with a class striker, even if he wasn’t appreciated here.
I think that’s entirely possible. But would that have dug an even deeper financial hole?
It’s a question I’ve asked before but I do wonder whether if we’d have won promotion under Alexander would we have been:
a) better off and living in a land of milk & honey for the last 5 years
b) have fallen back down the leagues just as quickly and maybe even have gone bust?I’d hope for a) but I do wonder if b) was the most likely.
145% wages-to-turnover.
2 users thanked author for this post.
I would have thought so “on police advice”, at least for the first season!
Jon Walters anyone?
Cox ,Hill, Daws, and Wilcox.?
If Hill has anything it’s as a racconteur; Cox is alright, Daws spoke quite well and Wilcox too. There’s no comparison.
As I mentioned earlier, a good coach would give the players freedom to make not only in-play decisions, but also about the tactical approach for each match. For some reason many managers / coaches are stuck in the 1980’s and seem to believe that they should do all the decision making and thinking for players.
Interesting – one of the things I notice about Guardiola’s sides is that players don’t necessarily think for themselves because they have to be part of the team system. Or, put another way, individual expression is sacrificed for the greater good.
Of course, I agree with you that the “shouting & bollocking” style of management is an anachronism in the modern world.
2 users thanked author for this post.
£220 to stand at 6th tier football? I dunno, it sounds a lot to me.
Especially when they’re a division lower than they were last season….
TBF, none of the above is news, it’s all just speculation. I don’t think it’s that uncommon for loan players to check back in with their parent clubs from time-to-time. Odd to be doing it on one of our matchdays though.
Do you think he knows his best 11 yet?
Nevermind 11, I’d settle for knowing his best 16.
Clubs aren’t really interested in season ticket holders once they’ve got their money, so the money is in the casuals (glory boys in my day) why should it be cheap for them when their not prepared to commit, they don’t turn up very often so make them pay, same in most other situations flights, holidays, buy a ticket for a concert or pay on the door, like NI says win games you’ll get the bums on seats.
Your argument doesn’t really hold up there. Do you pay less with Ryanair just because you take a flight every week? No.
That might be a suitable model where demand outstrips supply but that’s not the case at GP is it? Every seat unsold is a lost opportunity; even if you sell it for £1 that’s £1 more than you would otherwise have got, there’s no variable cost involved in selling more seats.
2 users thanked author for this post.
I’ve said it before plenty of times, the people most likely to be put off by the cost are the casual fans so why do clubs charge them the most? £20+ for 6th tier football is absolutely laughable. If you want to get bums on seats, prices have to be reduced.
2 users thanked author for this post.
This is the FIFA rule, so I’m still a bit confused how this is allowed:
Players may be registered with a maximum of three clubs during one season.
During this period, the player is only eligible to play official matches for
two clubs. As an exception to this rule, a player moving between two clubs
belonging to associations with overlapping seasons (i.e. start of the season in
summer/autumn as opposed to winter/spring) may be eligible to play in official
matches for a third club during the relevant season, provided he has fully
complied with his contractual obligations towards his previous clubs.What happened to the rule about not playing for more than 2 clubs in a single season? I’m surprised he can play for Eastleigh.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Not exactly lacking in options in that position and Bunker was a bit of a Justin Walker, not sure how much of a loss it will be to be honest.
I trust he’s going on what he sees in training, his approach to each game, and a longer term vision for the team, rather than randomness. He’s got a lot of players to deal with and only just getting to know them mentally and physically.
Yes, let’s hope your right, I just wonder whether it’s wise to chop & change selections & players so frequently. Time will tell!
I’m still a bit concerned by the Random Team Generator approach to selection – Fewster in & straight out, Whitehouse appearing from nowhere, discarding Elliott & Sembie-Ferris so quickly. But it seemed to make a bit of a difference, remains to be seen if this will be the new plan or just a lucky guess.
I reckon Hilton should sack Dean and appoint WonderGoals as manager.
Been crying out for that option for years, his tactical analysis is unlike anyone else’s.
Given we’re pretty much down now, is there any point playing any of the loan players unless there’s a realistic chance of them being with us next season?
I genuinely believe we’d have been no worse off if Nelson had continued with no new signings.
It’s not all down to Jimmy, but the gamble to sign so many players has not paid off.With 1 win in 6 games, we literally couldn’t be much worse off!
Ultimately, whatever Dean’s pluses & minuses, we are still reaping Swann’s legacy and will continue to do so for a while yet.
4 users thanked author for this post.
Where are the goals going to come from?
-
AuthorPosts