How long do you have to inhabit a country before you can say that you came from there? 30,000 years seems a pretty long time to me, however we can swap opinions forever but nothing is going to change soon in the Middle East and I thought the Indian connection was pretty relevant in terms of how they were treated after being there so long but I understand you will have a different narrative and opinion to which you are rightly entitled but it gets us in the never ending stalemate cycle where a lot of threads naturally end up. It’s called debate and discussion which is so vital in a democracy.