I have done rating marks on Scunthorpe matches for a few years, and consider them to be fair in general, and probably 90% of my marks fall into the scale talked about by Lesgeo, but in my opinion different supporters have slightly different views on players than other fans, so although it is impossible for all to give the same rating marks, it would also be pointless doing it in the first place.
For example I gave rating marks of 4 to both Rowe and O’Malley in last nights match, simply because they both had very poor games in my opinion, I class 5 or 6 as average marks, but their performances last night fell lower than average, so a 4 in my opinion suggests that there is room for improvement, so if you do not agree, just please pass on, or issue your own rating marks.
It is in my opinion very difficult to just use marks of 5-6-7 and 8, I often give a 9, and some times a 4, last night I had two ratings of 4, and just the one rating mark of 9 for the Ref who I thought was outstanding on the night.
Interesting to read the views of other supporters.
