Like you say though, none of them have shown it consistently, with the exception of Karacan.
But I think Gilliead is very over-rated. He has barely scored or created a goal this season and for my money he’s been churning out some very modest performances all season. I thought he looked good in centre mid early on in the season but as a winger I don’t think he affects games. The fact he’s even being talked about as our best player is a reflection of the situation we’re in, I think.